Friday, October 22, 2010

a mash up: PackerHomosexualityPolygamyThingy

This one's just a quickie, mostly w/ links to stuff other people have said. But it has come together in my brain as deserving mention all in one place, so HERE YOU GO. All in One Place.

Earlier this month, the Mormon's had their semi-annual General Conference (a really big deal w/ sermons broadcast internationally) and the guy who is next in line to lead the church made some fairly backwards comments about homosexuality that set off a virtual firestorm amongst the Mormon blogging world (here's Joanna Brooks and Jana Riess on the subject for starters.) Later, that guy's sermon was cleaned up and softened a bit, modified before it was re-printed on the official Mormon website. But the damage was done, fights breaking out EVERYwhere. Especially on facebook which I am avoiding lately but still somehow managed to get involved in one of these throw-downs which happened to have A LOT of testimony-bearing involved (the "god-said-so-THERE-I-WIN" debate method.) Of course, polygamy was invoked (that link not specifically about the homosexuality comments, but a good read anyways) cuz yes, Mormon's shouldn't pretend that didn't happen (again, that link is not about the controversy, but fun article about polyandry and sex w/a subtle nod to mainstream Mormonism, as that particular FB throw-down involved someone trying to re-write polygamy.). Also there were questions about how the church has reversed it's positions on controversial social/political stances in the past and What Does That Mean Now?? People even just came out and asked "Exactly WHAT do you want the church to DO?" (that post got A LOT of comments.) Right about then I happened to be reading in Marriage: a History, concerning when US anti-miscegenation laws were starting to be repealed in the 1950's-1970's, and how this gem of an argument was used in support of said laws:
"The Almighty God created the races, white, black, yellow, malay, and red, and he placed them on separate continents... The fact that he separated the races shows that he did not intend for the races to mix"
Anyhoo... it really just got me thinking how much things can get messed up with folks try to start invoking The Almighty.

2 comments:

Jessica Steed said...

What a great post.
I love how many links you have!

You make an absolutely great point. Mark loves to watch Christian philosophers and Atheists debate (Hitchens, I think?) and there are just so many good points by the atheists about why god would do so many things that people claim he does.

Polygamy, anti-homosexuality, anti-mixed-racial marriage, terrorism, there are tons of examples of things that people believe God wants. It's hard to take it all in.

G said...

thanks jess :)

and I don't mean to throw the baby out with the bathwater: I do think that belief in God can be a significant source of joy/meaning in many peoples lives.
But wow what a mess belief in God can make of things sometimes.